Lyle begins to develop feelings for Mattie, and the pressure of juggling two women in the house drives him to have a serious talk with Lauren. Ryan makes a mortifying mistake after taking a swig out of a stray whiskey bottle.
Thirteen years after their high school prom, Ted still has a crush on Mary. Finally deciding to act on his feelings, he hires Pat, a private investigator, to find her. Pat lies about what he's discovered because the sleazy detective has fallen for Mary.