It Had to Be You Cast Michael Vartan Frankie Muniz Natasha Henstridge James A. Baffico Joseph Baldwin Jennifer Bassey Joelle Carter George DiCenzo George Ede Tod Engle Larry Fleischman David Healy Edward Hibbert Stephen Love Jeff Mazzola Lorraine Mazzola Tracey Morton Phyllis Newman Garry Pastore John Polce Faith Prince Michael Rispoli Emmy Rossum Tamar Schoenberg Tony Sirico Phil Stein Don Stephenson Joseph Tudisco Rebecca Wisocky Olivia d'Abo
