It's a day of disturbing realizations when Mitchell manages to ruin one of Jay's proudest golf moments, Phil overhears something that may forever change how he sees his little girl and Gloria stumbles upon Claire's dangerous little secret.
When Reverend Paul recruits Kyle and Mandy to the church bowling team, Mike is left with two unappealing options for Team Baxter, Ryan and Jen. Meanwhile, Vanessa anxiously awaits an endorsement from the Teacher’s Association for her Assembly campaign.
While fighting over the remote control, Adam reaches a defining moment in his relationship with Barry when they accidentally discover a "channel between the channels" that appears on TV. Meanwhile, Beverly grows tired of seeing so many women with Pops.
When Kyle and Mandy individually reveal a secret to Mike and Vanessa respectively, they are sworn not to tell the other. Meanwhile, Ryan invites Mike to be a guest on his podcast and Vanessa and the girls devise a plan to pay back a ride waiter.
Phil's judgment becomes clouded when he goes car shopping with his new buddy, Andre. Meanwhile, Jay is determined to get to his high school reunion with Gloria and Manny in tow, and Lily loses her favourite stuffed animal on a public metro train.
George is intrigued when a woman mistakes him for her boyfriend. Elaine becomes unpopular when she criticizes the movie 'The English Patient.' Jerry is drawn into a weightlifting contest with 80-year-old Izzy.
A young diabetic boy goes missing from his bed, and time is running out to get him insulin. A criminal couple known for producing child pornography is spotted with the boy, but they are not willing to help the investigation.
An original Superman costume catches Rick and Corey's attention. Rick wants to fetch a good price for a retro computer, while Corey determines the value of two vintage music posters. Chumlee tries to get a good deal for a 1980s Rhodes piano.